The short version

In most insurers, two groups of people do two different jobs. Most work in the business: they underwrite, broke, handle claims and keep the accounts. A few work on the business: they are the transformation team, and their job is to change how everyone else works.

The typical split is about 5% and 95%. A small team tries to change the work of a large one. It rarely succeeds. The 5% do not do the work, and the 95% are not asked to change it.

Change the mix. If the 95% spent 5% of their time working on the business, finding waste and cutting it, the firm would gain far more than any transformation team can deliver. Its people would also be happier and more satisfied, because they would be fixing the things that frustrate them every day.

In the business, and on the business

Working in the business is doing the work. Working on the business is improving how the work is done.

Insurance has kept the two apart. Improvement is given to a separate team, with its own plan and its own budget. The people who do the work are consulted, and then changed.

The waste in an insurer is valueless complexity, and it is found in the detail of daily work. See Valueless complexity: what waste means in insurance. The people who can see it are the people who do that work. A team that stands outside it cannot.

Why teams hold on

The experts in each team hold on to their complexities. They built them, mastered them and are valued for knowing them. Held team by team across the business, those complexities hold the entire organisation back.

This cannot be fixed from outside the team. An instruction to simplify is met with a defence of why this process is different. The people who hold the complexity are the ones best placed to see which parts deliver value, and they have to choose to let the rest go.

A different mindset

What stands in the way is mindset. Most people defend their practices and processes, and will tell you theirs is already the most efficient way. That is a natural response where a flaw in the process is treated as a flaw in the person.

Lean organisations work the other way. Their employees compete to find waste and eliminate it. Finding something wrong in how you work is celebrated and rewarded.

That is a completely different mindset, and it is set by leaders: by what they ask about, what they praise and what they fund. So the task for leaders is to awaken a spirit of Lean and continuous improvement in their teams. Most leaders need help with that. It is a change in how people see their own work, which no new process or system will bring about.

Teams built round a shared goal

This is where agile, cross-functional teams make the difference. A team that brings together the business, operations, technology and data around a shared goal looks at the whole of the work: people, process, technology and data together.

Such a team does not reach for technology as the answer to every problem. Often the fix is a decision, a simpler process or a clearer owner, and the team has everyone it needs to make that change.

And because the experts are in the team, working to a goal they share, letting go of a complexity becomes their own choice, not something done to them.

Making it the way the firm runs

Removing waste once is a project. Keeping it out is a way of running the business.

  • The people doing the work find the waste. They see it every day. They need the time, the permission and the means to remove it.
  • Someone owns each value stream end to end. One named leader is accountable for the whole flow, across the teams it passes through.
  • A standing team makes the changes. Business and technology people stay together after go-live and release small improvements often.
  • Flow is measured. Time from submission to quote, items touched more than once, work waiting in queues. What is measured weekly improves.
  • Improvement is funded as a capability. A steady budget, not a business case for every change.

Questions for the executive team

  • Is change in our business done by a small team to everyone else, or by everyone as part of their job?
  • How much of an underwriter's or claims handler's week is set aside for improving how they work?
  • When someone finds a fault in how their team works, are they thanked or blamed?
  • What did our leaders last praise: a target hit, or a piece of waste removed?
  • Who owns our most important value stream from end to end?

Further reading

The Toyota Way, by Jeffrey K. Liker, is the clearest account of where this thinking comes from. It sets out the principles behind Toyota's way of working, which rest on two ideas: continuous improvement, and respect for the people who do the work. It was written about manufacturing, and most of it carries over to insurance.

How Bind helps

We help leaders awaken a spirit of Lean and continuous improvement in their teams, so that the people who hold the complexity are the ones who find it and let it go.

  • Leading the change: working with executives and team leaders to make finding waste something people are recognised for, not blamed for.
  • Cross-functional teams: forming teams across business, operations, technology and data, around shared goals and a value stream they own.
  • Operating model: value stream ownership, standing teams and the habits of continual improvement.